Jin Hua Qing Gan Fang made in lab.

The rules are different here in the United States. Hyde Park Holistic Center in Cincinnati recently received a warning letter from the Food & Drug Administration that read like many others having to do with nutritional supplements and the H1N1 virus. In China, though, the same admonishment could not be heard.

First, the FDA’s message to Hyde Park, which operates the Web site drdahlman.com: “The FDA has determined that your website offers a product for sale that is intended to diagnose, mitigate, prevent, treat or cure the H1N1 Flu Virus in people. This product has not been approved, cleared, or otherwise authorized by FDA for use in the diagnosis, mitigation. prevention, treatment, or cure of the H1N1 Flu Virus.”

The product in question is “4 Life Transfer Factor Plus Tri Factor,” which is sold in a password-protected store on the site. The product apparently supports immune system health or, as the FDA quotes Dr. Dahlman on one of his Web pages, “I firmly believe that use of this product will sufficiently upregulate your immune system and should be a primary part of your strategy to avoid the dangers of swine flu (H1N1 virus).”

It’s worth noting that Dr. Dahlman is not an M.D. His online biography says he is “a Chiropractic Physician with a degree in Nutrition, is Director of The Hyde Park Holistic Center in Cincinnati, Ohio and specializes in treatment of chronic health problems using nutritional, herbal and homeopathic therapies.”

If Dr. Dahlman were in China, he might have gotten praise rather than criticism. On Dec. 16, Chinese medical specialists said they had developed a Chinese herbal medication to treat H1N1. An article from the official Chinese news agency, Xinhua, quotes Wang Chen, president of Beijing’s Chaoyang Hospital, as saying the medication “can shorten patients’ fever period and improve their respiratory systems. Doctors have found no negative effects on patients who were treated in this way.”

The article adds that the herbal formula, called “Jin Hua Qing Gan Fang,” had been tested at 11 hospitals on 410 people who exhibited mild symptoms of H1N1. With success in treatment over a five-month period, the makers were seeking international patents.

The herbal medication is being positioned as a lower-cost alternative to Tamiflu, which WHO recommends for the treatment of H1N1.
Interestingly, the article quotes Cris Tunon, a senior officer at the WHO office in China, as saying that “WHO welcomes the clinical results.”

It’s unlikely the herbal medication would get the same greeting in the United States. The FDA has warned a number of companies with herbal products to stop making H1N1-related claims. Twice in 2009, the AHPA has advised against the use of dietary supplements to prevent or treat the flu. What happens when “Jin Hua” is marketed on American shores?

• None Found

A review of the company’s website reveals that they offer a selection of Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) products.
According to the FDA, the company is recalling the following products that contain ephedra:

Wu Yao Shun Qi San
Qing Bi Tang (Nasal Cleanser)
Zhong Fong Huo Luo Wan (Stroke Revito Formula)
Xiao Qing Long Tang (Little Green Dragon)
Ding Chuan Tang
Xiao Xu Ming Tang
Feng Shi Zhi Tong Wan (Joint Relief)
Guo Min Bi Yan Wan
Fang Feng Tong Sheng San

In addition, the company is also recalling two products containing aristolochic acid, a carcinogen and nephrotoxin found in certain plants and botanicals. The FDA cited risks of serious kidney damage or kidney failure, as well as an increased risk of kidney cancer, for the recall.

Finally, the recall includes a product sold as “Seng Jong Tzu Tong Tan” that the apparently contains human placenta. Placentophagy supplementation? That’s a new one for me.

The release notes that no illnesses have been reported to the company to date in connection with these products and the company has ceased distribution of all of these products. The press release contains a statement from Herbal Science that says the company “apologizes for any inconvenience and expresses its concerns for the health of consumers by conducting a voluntary recall action. Herbal Science International, Inc. promises to ensure quality and integrity of all its products and the company is working closely with the FDA in the recall process.”

Interestingly, the company website contains no reference to the recall. Moreover, as of this writing, all the products recalled are still listed for sale here.

• None Found