My article discusses class actions challenging advertising and labeling claims for dietary supplements and food products in which companies are accused of making product claims that are unfair or misleading to a large group of consumers. I note that in these cases consumer experiences with a product and its claims may differ greatly and, as a result, individual lawsuits, instead of class actions, may be more appropriate.
I argue in favor of an individualized approach to cases over deceptive claims. In Celsius, the court recognized that this plaintiff could never prove whether the Celsius supplement product’s performance claims are true or not. Since this was an essential element of his claim, he lacked standing to show how he was damaged, and the class action case was dismissed.
As I have said elsewhere, I believe that we are seeing the beginning of a trend toward more individualized treatment of cases involving deceptive claims, and away from class actions. The defense strategy companies adopt is critical and must focus the court on the plaintiff’s proof.
To read the decision in Fletcher v. Celsius, click here.